I love matte lipstick as much as the next person, but it’s time to draw a line in the sand. Thinking back, it’s difficult to pinpoint exactly when our collective obsession with non-shiny finishes started. Perhaps it was 2013 when Rihanna declared Ruby Woo, a classic matte, her favorite lip shade. But given the amount of attention they get, you’d think they were the only type of lipstick that actually existed. Let’s switch gears and show some much-needed love to the best MAC cream lipsticks, shall we?
Anyone who has ever walked into a MAC brick-and-mortar store, or shopped online at one of the many places it’s sold (Ulta and Nordstrom to name a few) is well aware of one thing. There is a lot to choose from. Correction: there’s a whole lot to choose from. Though there are a couple dozen best-sellers that makeup bloggers and experts will routinely recommend, the truth is you could spend a huge chunk of your life attempting to discover each and every shade in their ever-expanding repertoire. Our advice? Start by exploring according to finish.
We’ve already waxed poetic about some of our favorite matte colors, including Russian Red and Heroine, but the creams are next-level in our humble opinion. That’s because the cream finishes aren’t just your typical “cream.” Unlike mattes which are just, well, matte, MAC cream lipsticks are split into sub-categories so you get even more variety. They include cream, satin, cremesheen, lustre and Amplified (aka ultra-creamy). And our top 12 includes at least one option from each.
A statement-making shade that’s somewhere between a deep red and muted pink.
A high-shine lippie whose pink tint will remind you of the inside of a grapefruit.
A cremesheen red with yellow undertones that almost feels like a lip balm.
A delicate rose plum with a buildable formula that won’t ever feel too heavy.
You’ll fall in love with the cushiony feel of this muted pink-beige. A go-to shade for low-key days.
Girl About Town
Ultra-creamy and ultra-bright, this bright fuchsia with blue undertones is a must for those with cool skin undertones.
What isn’t there to love about a bright orange on those days when you need a pick-me-up?
This cremesheen is the perfect blend of red and purple.
The satin-y, golden-brown lipstick we’ve been searching for all our lives.
An intense pink coral you’ll be happy you had this spring and summer.
A simple cream plum for the purple lovers.
This lustre pink is the perfect mid-point between super bright and ultra-dark.
Our mission at STYLECASTER is to bring style to the people, and we only feature products we think you’ll love as much as we do. Please note that if you purchase something by clicking on a link within this story, we may receive a small commission of the sale and the retailer may receive certain auditable data for accounting purposes.