’Tis the season for two lipstick trends that always take center stage come fall: vampy and nude (or neutral). The former is less about complementing your skin tone and more about evoking the mood or feel of the season. Neutrals, on the other hand, look best when they closely matches your skin tone.
According to Mally Roncal, seasoned makeup artist and founder of Mally Beauty, the best way to do this is by pulling down your bottom lip and selecting a shade that most closely matches the inside. “That color tends to be a little darker than your natural lip color and looks very flattering,” she says. Your skin’s undertones also play a role in determining the most flattering shade for your face. There are many ways you can go about doing this, but the easiest would be to check the color of your veins on your forearm. If they look blue, you’ve got cooler undertones, and if they appear more green, consider yourself warm.
Generally speaking, Roncal recommends the following guidelines:
For fair skin: “You want to stray from nude shades that have warmer undertones, like reds and oranges. Instead, opt for a nude that has cooler undertones, such as blues and purples.” For fair skin with a summer tan, stick with cooler undertones, but opt for a darker hue.
For tan/olive skin: “Tan skin tends to have warmer undertones, so you should stick with warmer undertones when selecting your perfois nude. A beautiful chestnut lip color works great with this skin tone. I would recommend staying away from creamy vanilla shades,” says Roncal.
For deep brown skin: “Opt for a shade that has a red undertone, like a gorgois cocoa or cappuccino, and nix the beige nudes,” says Roncal.
With that being said, here are some options for each category.
For Deep Brown Skin: Fenty Beauty Mattemoiselle Plush Matte Lipstick in Shawty
A warm chestnut for rich, deep skin tones.
$18 at Fenty Beauty
For Deep Brown Skin: Flesh Fleshy Lips Sheer Lipstick in Slick
A rich mahogany that perfectly compliments beautiful brown skin.
$18 at Flesh Beauty
For Deep Brown Skin: Mented Cosmetics Brown Bare Lipstick
A flawless blend of brown and pink undertones with a satin finish.
$16.50 at Mented Cosmetics
For Deep Brown Skin: Bobbi Brown Lipstick in Nude
This neutral lipstick has more pink than brown tones if you want just a little pop of color.
$29 at Sephora
For Deep Brown Skin: Fresh Sugar Tinted Lip Treatment SPF 15 in Honey
This rich brown shade delivers a sheer tint of color and sun protection.
$24 at Nordstrom
For Tan or Deep Brown Skin: Christian Louboutin Velvet Matte Lip Colour in Just Nothing
A neutral lipstick with warm undertones and a matte finish.
$90 at Net-A-Porter
For Tan/Olive Skin: bareMinerals Gen Nude Matte Liquid Lipstick in Friendship
A silky cream formula that dries down to a non-flaky, matte finish.
$19 at bareMinerals
For Tan/Olive Skin: Kiehl’s Butterstick Lip Treatment SPF 30 in Naturally Nude
A low-key lipstick formulated with lemon butter and coconut oil for ample moisture.
$19.50 at Kiehl’s
For Tan/Olive Skin: Charlotte Tilbury Hot Lips Lipstick in Super Cindy
A supermodel-inspired taupey nude with warm undertones.
$34 at Charlotte Tilbury
For Tan/Olive Skin: Lipstick Queen Nothing but the Nudes Lipstick in Nothing but the Truth
A beige nude that delivers just enough color on those low-key, almost makeup-free days.
$24 at Ulta
For Fair Skin: Bite Beauty Amuse Bouche Lipstick in Meringue
A peachy nude made with 12 different oils for moisture and comfortable wear.
$26 at Sephora
For Fair Skin: Pat McGrath Labs MatteTrance Lipstick in Christy
A luxurious-feeling lippie that delivers intense color with just one swipe.
$38 at Pat McGrath Labs
For Fair Skin: Flower Beauty Hydrasilk Ultimate Lip Butter in Naked Petal
A gorgeous lip butter that feels like a balm, but delivers the color payoff of a lipstick.
$9 at Flower Beauty
For Fair Skin: Becca Ultimate Lipstick in Love in Bare
A light pinky nude infused with hyaluronic acid.
$24 at Sephora
Honest Liquid Lipstick in Forever
This creamy mauve is made with a hydrating vegan formula.
$12.99 at Honest Beauty
Our mission at STYLECASTER is to bring style to the people, and we only feature products we think you’ll love as much as we do. Please note that if you purchase something by clicking on a link within this story, we may receive a small commission of the sale.